Council Reports Teacher Tenure Weakening
article by James Dugan | January 26, 2012
As a part of their 2011 State Teacher Policy Yearbook, the National Council on Teacher Quality (NCTQ), teacher tenure was one focus of the report. In the report, the council found that more states are changing their tenure policies to have greater freedom to remove ineffective teachers.
According to the report, more states are implementing additional requirements for tenure. In 2009 it was reported that no state required student performance to be included in the tenure process, now eight states do.
“There's a real shift to saying all kids, especially our most disadvantaged kids, have access to really high quality and effective teachers. And, that's it's not OK for kids to have ... an ineffective teacher year after year,” Sandi Jacobs, vice president of the NCTQ said to The Associated Press.
Rhode Island, Florida, Colorado and Nebraska have all stated that they have implemented changes to the tenure process that will allow for teachers to be removed if they get multiple ineffective ratings. For example, the state of Rhode Island says that if a teacher receives two years of ineffective ratings, they will be dismissed.
This analysis comes at a time when increasingly more research is showing that good teachers can have a strong impact on a student’s life. In one recent report it showed that students with good teachers make substantially more money later in life.
However, in spite of these changes, many states still have tenure policies that enable ineffective teachers to remain in schools.
According to the Yearbook report, only three states—Florida, Idaho and Rhode Island—have removed tenure from teaching. And for many states there are no restrictions or requirements to receive tenure other than teaching for the minimum number of years, with only eight states requiring evidence of student learning.
“That's the problem with tenure, everybody gets it,” Jacobs said. “If you're held to a high bar where you've really demonstrated that you are effective in the classroom, then there's nothing wrong with that as long as the due process rights that you do get are reasonable.”
Part of the reason for this reluctance to change is that many teachers feel that there is an over-reliance on standardized tests that don’t accurately reflect the students’ knowledge. At the same time, many teachers are worried that by removing or weakening tenure regulations, teachers will be afraid to innovate and express what they feel is best for the students.
Also according to the report, states also have difficulties changing the policies because tenure decisions are often a local issue that is very specific to each individual district and school. However, the report explains that because of the changes being made in tenure policies, tenure is not completely off limits to the states and leads to a need to improve teacher evaluations.
“If we know who the effective teachers are, if we know what kind of an impact effective teachers can have on individual kids and on our society overall, then why wouldn't we take the obvious step of utilizing the information on who are the most effective teachers to make our staffing decisions?” said Michelle Rhee, former schools chancellor in Washington, D.C. and CEO of the student advocacy group StudentsFirst.
More Education News
-
Laid-off Teachers Trained in New Areas
Around the country, more teachers are facing lay offs as districts and states struggle with budget shortages. However, various school districts are forming partnerships with universities and other organizations to get these laid-off teachers credentials in other high-need areas like math, science and special education.
-
Newark Plans New 'Teachers Village'
Ground was recently broken on a new mixed-use development, dubbed the ‘Teachers Village’ in Newark, N.J. that would provide facilities for three charter schools, a day care facility, housing and ground-level retail space. The project comes at a time when Governor Chris Christie has been paying special attention to education in the state of New Jersey.
-
'Respect Project' to Focus on Teachers
Using the Race to the Top contest as a model, the U.S. Department of Education is using $5 billion in grant money to sponsor a teacher development contest. The contest encourages states to overhaul the teaching profession and improve teacher quality. Among some of the changes the department is pushing are: higher teaching salaries, compensation tied to performance and more selective and improved teaching colleges.
-
Unified Sports Helps Special Needs Kids
With a new article on bullying in schools almost every week, it is hard to imagine a place where students all treat each other as equals and with respect. However, more schools have taken extra steps to help stop bullying cases against special needs students.One way schools have made students with disabilities feel more involved within the school is through Project Unify.
-
Poverty Gap Widens as Racial Gap Closes
New research out of Stanford University shows that while efforts to close the achievement gap between White students and minority students has been slowly working, the achievement gap between wealthier and poorer students is widening. According to the study the gap between rich students and poor students is now twice as large as the gap between black and white students.
-
Black History Taught in Various Ways
The month of February, designated as Black History Month, has many schools gearing up with various plans to help students learn about African American history and heritage. While many schools focus on the civil rights era and African Americans rising up from slavery, some are focusing on different aspects of Black history. Schools around the country have many planned different events and lessons planned ranging from specific events with guest speakers to involving African American heritage in subjects other than history to expand on this rich part of American history.
-
States Look at Holding Back 3rd Graders
Four states are exploring new laws that would require third grade students to be held back if they do poorly on reading exams. According to a new bill introduced by lawmakers in Colorado, even though parents would be able to request their student be promoted, ultimately it would be up to the district to make final decisions. Iowa, Tennessee, and New Mexico are also exploring similar legislation.
-
Schools push for early help for students
In an effort to ensure that education funding is spent more wisely, various school leaders in Minnesota are pushing for early one-on-one interventions with children who may be identified as having learning disorders. By using a "response to intervention" model in helping students learn, many feel that not only will it help all students in their achievement but also lower the number of students diagnosed with learning disabilities, thus lowering special education costs.